Powered by Trust.Reviews
Insolvency Trust Disputes - Goldman Lawyers
CREDITOR RIGHTS, RESTRUCTURING AND TRUST LITIGATION

INSOLVENCY LITIGATION LAWYERS: ASSET PROTECTION, TRUSTS, DEMANDS & LIQUIDATORS.

A plain-English guide to oppression claims, breaches of directors’ duties, company deadlock, and how share buy-outs and winding-up work in Australia.

UNDERTSANDING INSOVENCY TRUSTEE & LIQUIDATORS COURT DISPUTES

Your Guide

A company is insolvent when it cannot pay debts as and when they fall due. Formal processes include voluntary administration, liquidation, restructuring and receivership, while personal insolvency is governed by bankruptcy law. Each process has strict gateways, priority rules and review rights.

Trust and asset disputes can involve the validity and administration of a trust, trustee duties, access to information, distributions, removal of trustees and claims that trust property should be available to creditors. The facts, governing instrument and statutory context must be analysed together.

Jaswinder Says

In insolvency work, timing and evidence determine leverage: a missed deadline or untested assumption can change the entire recovery position.

— Jaswinder (Jas) Sekhon · Director / Principal

How the INSOLVENCY Process Unfolds

FROM DEFAULT TO REVIEW AND DISTRIBUTION

Insolvency disputes usually begin with default, a demand, an appointment or a disagreement about control of assets or trust property. The appointment of an administrator, liquidator, receiver or trustee changes who controls the process and how claims must be advanced. Creditors often need to lodge proofs, preserve security rights and respond quickly to reports, meetings and proposed distributions.

Clawback, priority and trust claims may require detailed tracing, expert accounting evidence and court directions or substantive proceedings. The pathway below is a high-level guide and must be adapted to the appointment, asset position, security structure and limitation periods.

How much does an insolvency dispute cost?

INDICATIVE CUMULATIVE COSTS AND TIME

The cost profile depends on whether the issue is confined to creditor review, requires an administrator’s determination, proceeds to winding-up or involves complex trust and clawback litigation. Forensic accounting, document reconstruction, multiple entities and disputed beneficial ownership can materially increase the work required.

The charts are illustrative and do not replace a written scope or estimate for the particular appointment and recovery strategy. A disciplined merits and recoverability assessment should be completed before significant litigation expenditure is committed.

Recovery strategy should be tested against asset availability, security, priority, limitation periods, the administrator’s evidence and the likely net return after legal, expert and insolvency-administration costs.

All figures are indicative planning ranges only, exclude GST and disbursements unless stated, and must be verified in a written estimate for the specific matter.

Videos, Guides and Articles

INSIGHTS AND PRACTICAL GUIDANCE

Use these resources to understand the procedure, prepare more effectively and identify the questions that should be addressed before the next stage.

VIDEOS & GUIDES

Voluntary administration and liquidation — who controls the company

Who controls the company, what happens to claims and how creditor rights differ.

Statutory demands and trust disputes — the 21-day deadline and trustee claims

Who controls the company, what happens to claims and how creditor rights differ.

ARTICLES

STRESS TEST YOUR ASSET LOSS "RISKS" BEFORE INSOLVENCY

Key terms defined

GLOSSARY — INSOLVENCY & TRUST TERMS

Statutory demand a formal creditor’s demand; 21 days to pay or apply to set aside 

Voluntary
administration
an insolvency process where an administrator takes control

Liquidation the winding up of a company and distribution of its assets

Voidable transaction /
unfair preference
pre-appointment payments a liquidator can claw back

Trustee’s right
of indemnity
the trustee’s claim on trust assets for properly incurred liabilities

Breach of trust a trustee acting outside the trust deed or their duties.

Frequently Asked Questions

COMMON QUESTIONS

Insolvency runs on fixed statutory periods, and most of them cannot be extended once missed. These answers cover what happens to a company, what creditors can do, and where trust structures complicate things.

A company is insolvent when it cannot pay all its debts as and when they become due and payable. This is a cash flow test, not just a balance sheet test a company can hold valuable assets and still be insolvent if it cannot pay what is due now.

Voluntary administration is a rescue process. An administrator takes control of the company and investigates it. Creditors then vote on what happens next: end the administration, accept a deed of company arrangement, or wind the company up. Liquidation is the wind-up, assets are sold, claims are checked, and the money is shared out. Administration keeps options open; liquidation closes them.

You complete the prescribed proof of debt form and lodge it with the external administrator, attaching evidence such as invoices, contracts, statements and correspondence. The administrator then adjudicates on it. Poorly evidenced claims are commonly rejected or reduced, so lodge it properly the first time.

Yes. A liquidator can recover unfair preferences, uncommercial transactions, unreasonable director-related transactions and creditor-defeating dispositions where the statutory tests are met. Look-back periods vary, commonly six months for preferences involving unrelated parties, and up to four years or more for related parties. Defences exist, including good faith and running account arguments.

Broadly: secured creditors to the extent of their security, then the liquidator’s costs and remuneration, then priority employee entitlements such as wages, leave and (subject to caps) redundancy, then unsecured creditors sharing rateably. Shareholders rank last and usually receive nothing.

Yes. A court can remove and replace a trustee where the proper administration of the trust requires it, for example conflict of interest, misconduct, incapacity, or a breakdown that leaves the trustee unable to act impartially. The trust deed may also contain a removal power that avoids going to court.

It depends. Where a company acts as trustee the assets belong to the trust, but the trustee’s right of indemnity can be exercised for properly incurred trust liabilities. The answer turns on the trust deed, whether the trustee was validly removed, whether the debts were incurred in the trust’s business, and whether the structure survives challenge.

Yes, wholly or in part. If your claim is rejected you receive written notice, and you generally have a short period, commonly 14 days, to apply to the court to review the decision. These deadlines are strict, so diarise them the day the notice arrives.

Insolvent trading is where a director allows a company to incur a debt while it is already insolvent, or where it becomes insolvent because of that debt, and there were reasonable grounds to suspect insolvency. Directors can be personally liable for the resulting loss. Defences include the safe harbour provisions and reasonable reliance on information.

Very. Statutory demand set-aside applications (21 days), proof of debt reviews, voidable transaction claims and appeals all run on fixed statutory periods, and most cannot be extended once missed. In insolvency, delay almost always costs more than early advice would have.

Goldman Law

CONFIDENTIAL NO OBLIGATION HELP

INQUIRY OR DISCUSSION
WITH A SENIOR LAWYER

BOOK A CALL BACK




Book your legal strategy information meeting now with a senior lawyer

Fill in the form below to book a 30-minute no-obligation consulting session. 

I will reply within 24 hours.